It’s Time for Twitter Premium Accounts

December 19, 2008 | 3 Comments

Former TechCrunch writer Nick Gonzalez’s post “Who Owns Your Social Media Accounts“, as a reply to my Twitter Needs Better Username Policy (the ‘celtics’ fiasco), got me thinking…

This is the perfect opportunity for Twitter to start with Premium accounts. Charging whatever the price may be — $3/mo or $3/yr for example. The user then locks in their Twitter username and similar rules that govern domains are applied. First come, first served — and of course an arbitrator if there’s a trademark conflict.

A Twitter username can serve as an identity to someone, just as a phone number does. As Nick mentions, it’d be a cruel world if the phone company just swiped your cell phone number and changed it on you — wouldn’t it?

The question still remains, if my ‘celtics’ account had been all about Celtic Knots, would Twitter have confiscated my username and handed it over to the Boston Celtics NBA team? [Are they even sure it is the Boston Celtics NBA team, and not just some other person out there pretending to be them?]

Evan – Twitter needs a better policy on Usernames

December 19, 2008 | 66 Comments

Evan,

I have a bunch of Twitter usernames — I gobbled them up in March 2007. I’d consider them some of the “quality” ones. Almost like the domain game of 1995, I grabbed some of the best Twitter usernames, because I could see value in their use in the future.

I’ve been working and investing my own money in developing services to help make Twitter a better place. I came up with the first Twitter bots and have written extensively about Twitter on my blog. I’ve also helped with bugs and features via Al3x since SXSW ‘07.

18 months later and I’ve slowly been getting various accounts pulled from me. You claim that I’m in violation of your terms of service, specifically: “You must not abuse, harass, threaten, impersonate or intimidate other Twitter users.”

Well, I’m calling bullshit on you right now. Just say it, the Boston Celtics called and they want you to pull rank to get them in the front-row seats of the game (Twitter), when I’ve been holding those seats (username:celtics) for 18 months.

Last night, “celtics” was pulled from me. You moved my account to “bc_fan_news“. I’m running a fan account with news on the Boston ‘Celtics’. I’m not trying to impersonate them — my username’s profile clearly states it is a fan account, run by a fan, and not officially affiliated at all. In prior weeks, I lost ’stanford’ and ‘bostoncollege’. Why not give them [The Boston Celtics] the username ‘bostonceltics’ instead? Why was my ‘celtics’ one swiped? Why was anyone’s username swiped?

I’m just wondering, when does it end? My personal twitter account is ‘STP‘ — are you going to pull that from me when STP (motor oil company) or Stone Temple Pilots comes to you guys and claims trademark infringement? My initials are STP — as in, “Steven Thomas Poland.”

This is a slippery slope you guys are going down.

StockTwits just raised nearly $1 million — their business is based off Twitter. Definitely one of their assumptions is that they’ll be keeping their username ‘StockTwits’.

There are other Twitter accounts out there providing sports headlines and info about teams — so it’s obviously not a problem that I have many usernames. 

The point here is, you just made up an excuse as to why you pulled my username — and that’s not good policy. How does that make anyone feel comfortable investing in services/business on top of your platform, when it could all disappear at any moment for them?

Keep up the good work on Twitter, but please put a better policy in place here. I feel as though you’re allowing yourself to get bullied, likely because you don’t want to deal with any lawsuits — but how can anyone sue you — these are privately-owned usernames; not publicly-available domains. If a user is trying to impersonate, then I agree, pull their username from them. Otherwise, don’t give into these corporate and celebrity bullies that are just now, 18+ months later, jumping on the Twitter bandwagon.

Sincerely,

Steve Poland

Update: Allen Stern at CenterNetworks brings up the question, “Will Twitter need to setup a dispute-resolution process and review board?”

Update 2: Chris Lockwood makes another good point, which is what can be the case with any username/acronym/word: “The funny thing is that “celtics” is not automatically a reference to a sports team. There is an entire ethnic group of people who had that name long before basketball was invented.”

Update 3: I did know the Terms of Service when I signed up, but still the question is how do they determine who should keep the username they’ve been using: “We reserve the right to reclaim usernames on behalf of businesses or individuals that hold legal claim or trademark on those usernames.”

Update 4: If you were an $800K investor in StockTwits, wouldn’t you want a written letter from Twitter stating that the username ’stocktwits’ was no longer bound to the line above regarding the Terms of Service? Maybe there needs to be a process in place where companies/individuals can ensure that clause doesn’t apply to them?

Update 5: Some additional 1-liner comments by Dave Winer, Huffington Post, StockTwits investor Howard Lindzon

Update 6: Former TechCrunch writer Nick Gonzalez chimes in with a post of “Who Owns Your Social Media Accounts?” I reply with a post of my own, “It’s Time for Twitter Premium Accounts

Update 7: How did Evan deal with this at Blogger? There’s only one unique subdomain for ‘blogspot.com’ — so if the Boston Celtics had wanted to take away ‘celtics.blogspot.com’, would he have let them without warning to the current user of that blog?

The USA Spoiled You- Now Pull Your Panties Up.

December 12, 2008 | 3 Comments

It is amazing how “rich” the USA is — or at least how rich they think they are. I bet 90% of Americans that have access to a credit card, are stupid with their money. They overspend. They spend what they don’t have. Why? Because they can — the credit card companies have given them access to more cash then they should ever need in their lives.

It’s ridiculous. And it should be a crime. There should be some personal liability at the banks for the turmoil they have put people in, and this nation. There needs to be more financial independence in America. 

The media and stardom hasn’t helped — nor have the parents that neglect their children and then spend their riches on them, spoiling the hell out of them. It’s a downward spiral — little Johnny comes to school in $100 sneakers, and then little Mark [who comes from a poor family] wants the $100 sneakers, because little Johnny is cooler. Little Johnny is a spoiled brat — and it’s likely because his parents shouldn’t be parents and/or don’t have the time to spend with him, so they feel they can make it up by buying him blingin’ sneakers.

There shouldn’t even be credit cards. If your car is broke and you can’t afford to fix it this week, then take the bus for a week. Suck it up. Oh, it’s an additional hour of your life each day, waiting for the bus and such? Tough shit. 

I never had a financial plan. I had been in debt since I was 18, when I was given 5 credit cards from financial instititutions, while I was going to college. How did I get access to 5 credit cards? Seriously, someone should be sued. People aren’t taught financial responsibility — they are taught to spend, spend, spend! And that you don’t have to ever say no, just say yes!

I know, I know, I’m ranting here. But I’m saddened that people are in complete financial disstress and in messes they can’t get out of, without killing their “credit”. 

Make a plan. Plan how you’re going to get out of debt. Plan how you’re going to sock some money away in savings, while getting out of debt. Plan for what’s going to happen if you lose your job — plan to put 3-6 months of expenses in a savings account, “in case shit” happens.

It’s amazing how rich you feel when you’re out of debt — I was paying $500/mo to credit cards on a 5-year plan through a non-profit credit counseling company. You know what it’s like to not pay $500/mo now? It’s crazy madness! Now I put that money in savings. 

I make some decent money these days — my first goal was getting out of short-term debt (credit cards). I also owed my Mom some money that I had borrowed. After getting out of credit card for the first time in 11 years, it was such a huge weight lifted off my shoulders. Until you do it, you’ll never know what it feels like — it’s amazing. What was next? I drive a 1995 Nissan Altima with 160,000 miles on it. Of course the next thing for me to do is upgrade this car — hell, let’s get a new car under a lease.

FUCK THAT. I’m still driving that piece-of-shit car. I’m driving that sucker into the ground. It’s paid off. I have no payments on it. Your mindset changes, if you let it. You start to not think, “wow, how can I spend all this new money I have” and turns to “how do I conserve this cash”. In the case of the car — I like to say [and yes, this is inappropriate] — “I know the size of my own d*ck, I don’t need to show it off to everyone else.” I don’t need the self-esteem booster of some shiny new ride. Yeah, I know I could get one – but it’s not on my list of priorities.

My only priority now is diversifying my income streams to ensure one thing — never working for anyone again in my life. I never want to go back into corporate america.

I got distracted — because I didn’t have a plan. I’m throwing a big New Year’s Eve party in Buffalo NY for 500 people. Stupid, stupid, stupid. Throwing parties/events is not on my gameplan of diversified income streams. It’s something I’d like to do, but not for a few years, when I have full financial independence. Too late though, I’m going through with it. Lucky enough for me, it looks like I won’t lose my shirt on it (and I’ll turn a profit), but at what expense? It’s taken a lot of time in my life — a lot of time that should have been spent on my real priorities.

By the way — I disagree with the whole “I can’t make bad on debt, because my credit will be ruined for 7 years!” You know what, GOOD. Seriously, once you get to the new mentality where you’re only going to pay for what you can afford, you won’t even care about your credit being bad for 7 years — because you’ll never want to access credit anyhow. “What about a house?” — what about a house? Save your friggin money. Oh, you want one of those blingin’ homes in the suburbs? Marry someone with good credit. Or get a co-signer for that thing when the time arrives. Or get a private loan (you may need to put half down and pay like 12% on the other half, but hey, you’ll have your house). Who says a home is a good investment anyway? My buddy was telling me that he read somewhere that with all the money you put into closing costs, home improvements, mortgage interest, etc — that you’re just as well off investing that money into various securities, and just paying rent. Think about it.

Make a plan. Get out of debt. Even if it takes you 5 years to realize the end goal.

Make Money on Twitter, in minutes

December 5, 2008 | Leave a Comment

Good post for making money on Twitter by mixing in affiliate marketing on @esnagel’s blog: http://www.netnagel.com/2008/12/no-good-deed-goes-unpunished.html